Below is a list of all current inductees. The museum is planning 2023 inductions. Send a message to submit your South Jersey star and become a friend of the museum!
| Athletes/Players | Coaches | Contributors |
|---|---|---|
| Tex Robinson | Dr. Ed Salmon | Edgar Joyce |
| John Borican | Tony DiToma | Joseph Bowen |
| Richie Kates | Max Broomall | Rex Bowen |
| Leon ‘Goose’Goslin | John Rose | Harry T. Gamble |
| Rube Oldring | Howard Mason | Ralph A. Brandt |
| Harold Gould | Sophie Amaranto | Elton Hildreth |
| Harry ‘Butch’ Reynolds | Ben Lynch | George Moore iii |
| Brison Manor | Ken Fisher | Gene Hart |
| Don Money | Barney Fisher | Tom Lamaine |
| Larry Hisle | Louise Corson | Bill Campbell |
| Steve Romanik | Carl & Peg Gray | Chris ‘Wheels’ Wheeler |
| John ‘Duke’ Wuzzardo | Dave Shapiro | Dan Baker |
| Harvey Johnson | John Barbose | Dave Raymond |
| Lydell Mitchell | Herb Henry | Bob Shryock |
| Lawton Walter ‘Whitey’ Witt | Howard Furtek | Ed Hilt |
| George Jamison Jr. | Vinnie Woodruff | Bob McElwee |
| Pete Rose | Lee Ware | John Barr |
| Jack ‘Johnny’ Gross | Robin Shepard | Diane McGraw |
| Don ‘Tarzan’ Bragg | Arthur Kelly | Tom Burgoyne |
| Winona Schurnacher | Jimmy Ridgeway | Michael Barkann |
| Chris Widger | Samuel Hunter, Sr. | John Campani |
| Vince Papale | Urie Morris | Joe Kadlec |
| Andrew Bailey | Claudia McCarthy | Kristen Rodgers |
| Charlie Manuel | Ron Marino | Joe L. DeLuca, Sr. |
| Gary Dornhoefer | Larry Elwell | Kitty Peterson |
| Todd Frazier | Wilmer ‘Bunky’ Black | Salvy Blandino |
| Joe Frazier | Annie Wright | Larry Litwin |
| Brian Propp | Paul Rodio | Joe Blandino |
| John Henry ‘Pop’ Lloyd | Bob Hutchings | Greg Zyla |
| Harold Warfle | Ann Marie A. Mercado | Michael Catalano |
| Forest ‘Spook’ Jacobs | James Breech | Sal Paolantonio |
| Phil Villapiano | Kay Ballenger | |
| Johnny Gaudreau | Karen Horner | |
| Ken Dunek | Dave Ellen | |
| Alan Shaw | ||
| Rick MacLeish | ||
| Greg Luzinski | ||
| Frank LeMaster | ||
| Judy Dickinson | ||
| David “Lefty” Robinson | ||
| James “Art” Dorrington | ||
| Bradley Thomas Lidge | ||
| Jay Venuto | ||
| Ted Gruber | ||
| Seiki Murono | ||
| Adam Taliaferro | ||
| Larry Bowa | ||
| Tug McGraw | ||
| Milt Thompson | ||
| Dickie Noles | ||
| Adam Taliaferro | ||
| Jim McCormick | ||
| Brian Surace | ||
| Anthony Wayne “Bubba” Green | ||
| “Bob” Surace | ||
| Lou Piccone | ||
| Greg Zyla | ||
| Darren Rodell Seabrooks Ford | ||
| Theodore Henry (Ted) Ford | ||